Research Papers: Materials and Fabrication

Assessment of Long-Term Creep Rupture Strength of T91 Steel by Multiregion Rupture Data Analysis

[+] Author and Article Information
K. Maruyama

Department of Materials Science,
Graduate School of Engineering,
Tohoku University,
6-6-02 Aramaki-Aoba, Aoba-ku,
Sendai 980-8579, Japan
e-mail: maruyama@material.tohoku.ac.jp

J. Nakamura, K. Yoshimi

Department of Materials Science,
Graduate School of Engineering,
Tohoku University,
Sendai 980-8579, Japan

1Corresponding author.

Contributed by the Pressure Vessel and Piping Division of ASME for publication in the JOURNAL OF PRESSURE VESSEL TECHNOLOGY. Manuscript received July 7, 2015; final manuscript received January 14, 2016; published online February 23, 2016. Assoc. Editor: Haofeng Chen.

J. Pressure Vessel Technol 138(3), 031407 (Feb 23, 2016) (9 pages) Paper No: PVT-15-1152; doi: 10.1115/1.4032647 History: Received July 07, 2015; Revised January 14, 2016

Creep rupture strength of creep strength enhanced ferritic steels is often overestimated, and its evaluated value has been reduced repeatedly. In this paper, the cause of the overestimation is discussed, and the creep rupture strength of T91 steel is assessed with its updated creep rupture data. Effects of residual Ni concentration on the creep rupture strength and necessity of F factor in T91 steel are also discussed. Decrease in activation energy Q for rupture life in long-term creep is the cause of the overestimation, since conventional time–temperature parameter (TTP) methods cannot deal with the change in Q. Due to the decrease in Q, long-term creep rupture strength evaluated decreases as longer-term data points are added or shorter-term data points are discarded in the conventional TTP analysis. The long-term region with small values of activation energy and stress exponent is named region L2 in this paper. Region L2 appears in all the heats of T91 steel and plate products of Gr.91 steel. Since service conditions of the T91 steel are usually in region L2, the creep rupture strength under the service conditions should be evaluated from the rupture data in region L2 only. The 5 × 105 hrs rupture strength at 550 °C decreases from 129 MPa (evaluated from the whole data of T91 steel) to 79 MPa (evaluated from the data in region L2 only) with increasing cut-off time for data selection. The 105 hrs rupture strength at 600 °C also decreases from 87 MPa (whole data) to 70 MPa (region L2 only) despite sufficient number of long-term data points at 600 °C. Careful consideration on the data selection is necessary in evaluation of creep rupture strength of the T91 steel. A multiregion rupture data analysis (MRA) is helpful to select data points belonging to region L2.

Copyright © 2016 by ASME
Topics: Creep , Steel , Rupture
Your Session has timed out. Please sign back in to continue.


Kimura, K. , Kushima, H. , and Abe, F. , 2000, “ Heterogeneous Changes in Microstructure and Degradation Behavior of 9Cr-1Mo-V-Nb Steel During Long Term Creep,” Key Eng. Mater., 171–174, pp. 483–490. [CrossRef]
Maruyama, K. , Sawada, K. , and Koike, J. , 2001, “ Strengthening Mechanism of Creep Resistant Tempered Martensitic Steel,” ISIJ Int., 41(6), pp. 641–653. [CrossRef]
Danielsen, H. K. , and Hald, J. , 2006, “ Behaviour of Z Phase in 9-12%Cr Steels,” Energy Mater., 1(1), pp. 49–57. [CrossRef]
Maruyama, K. , 2008, “ Fracture Mechanism Map and Fundamental Aspects of Creep Fracture,” Creep-Resistant Steels, F. Abe , T. Kern , and R. Viswanathan , eds., Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK, pp. 350–364.
Masuyama, F. , 2010, “ Advanced Technology in Creep Life Prediction and Damage Evaluation for Creep Strength Enhanced Ferritic Steels,” High-Temperature Defect Assessment (HIDA-5), European Technology Development, Surry, UK, June 23–25.
Kimura, K. , and Takahashi, Y. , 2012, “ Evaluation of Long-Term Creep Strength of ASME Grade 91, 92, and 122 Type Steels,” ASME Paper No. PVP2012-78323.
Bendick, W. , Cipolla, L. , Gabrel, J. , and Hald, J. , 2009, “ New ECCC Assessment of Creep Rupture Strength for Steel Grade X10CrMoVNb9-1 (Grade 91),” Creep and Fracture in High Temperature Components, I. A. Shibli , and S. R. Holdsworth , eds., DEStech Publications, Lancaster, PA, pp. 56–67.
Maruyama, K. , and Yoshimi, K. , 2007, “ Influence of Data Analysis Method and Allowable Stress Criterion on Allowable Stress of Gr.122 Heat Resistant Steel,” ASME J. Pressure Vessel Technol., 129(3), pp. 449–453. [CrossRef]
Maruyama, K. , Nakamura, J. , and Yoshimi, K. , 2015, “ Prediction of Long-Term Creep Rupture Life of Grade 122 Steel by Multiregion Analysis,” ASME J. Pressure Vessel Technol., 137(2), p. 021403. [CrossRef]
National Institute for Materials Science, 2014, “ Data Sheets of the Elevated-Temperature Properties of 9Cr-1Mo-V-Nb Steel Tubes for Boilers and Heat Exchangers, 9Cr-1Mo-V-Nb Steel Plates for Boilers and Pressure Vessels and 9Cr-1Mo-V-Nb Seamless Pipe for High Temperature Service,” NIMS Creep Data Sheet No. 43A, NIMS, Tsukuba, Japan.
Orlova, A. , Bursik, J. , Kucharova, K. , and Sklenicka, V. , 1998, “ Microstructural Development During High Temperature Creep of 9% Cr Steel,” Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 245(1), pp. 39–48. [CrossRef]
Haney, E. M. , Dalle, F. , Sauzay, M. , Vincent, L. , Tournie, I. , Allais, L. , and Fournier, B. , 2009, “ Macroscopic Results of Long-Term Creep on a Modified 9Cr-1Mo Steel (T91),” Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 510–511, pp. 99–103. [CrossRef]
Nagae, Y. , Onizawa, T. , Takaya, S. , and Yamashita, Y. , 2014, “ Material Strength Evaluation for 60 Years Design in Japanese Sodium Fast Reactor,” ASME Paper No. PVP2014-28689.
Masuyama, F. , 2007, “ Creep Rupture Life and Design Factors for High-Strength Ferritic Steels,” Int. J. Pressure Vessels Piping, 84(1–2), pp. 53–61. [CrossRef]
EPRI, 2014, “ The Benefits of Improved Control of Composition of Creep-Strength-Enhanced Ferritic Steel Grade 91,” Electric Power Research Institute, Palo Alto, CA, Report No. 3002003472.
Kimura, K. , Sawada, K. , and Kushima, H. , 2010, “ Long-Term Creep Strength Property of Advanced Ferritic Creep Resistant Steels,” Sixth International Conference on Advances in Materials Technology, ASM International, Materials Park, OH, pp. 732–752.
Viswanathan, R. , 1989, “ Creep,” Damage Mechanisms and Life Assessment of High Temperature Components, ASM International, Metals Park, OH, pp. 59–110.
Kimura, K. , Sawada, K. , Kubo, K. , and Kushima, H. , 2004, “ Influence of Stress on Degradation and Life Prediction on High Strength Ferritic Steels,” ASME/JSME Paper No. PVP2004-2566.
Maruyama, K. , Baba, E. , Yokokawa, K. , Kushima, H. , and Yagi, K. , 1994, “ Errors of Creep Rupture Life Extrapolated by Time-Temperature Parameter Methods,” Tetsu-to-Hagane, 80(4), pp. 336–341.
Maruyama, K. , Armaki, H. G. , and Yoshimi, K. , 2007, “ Multi-Region Analysis of Creep Rupture Data of 316 Stainless Steel,” Int. J. Pressure Vessels Piping, 84(3), pp. 171–176. [CrossRef]
Oikawa, H. , and Iijima, Y. , 2008, “ Diffusion Behavior of Creep-Resistant Steels,” Creep-Resistant Steels, F. Abe , T. Kern , and R. Viswanathan , eds., Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK, pp. 241–264.
Maruyama, K. , Armaki, H. G. , Chen, R. P. , Yoshimi, K. , Yoshizawa, M. , and Igarashi, M. , 2010, “ Cr Concentration Dependence of Overestimation of Long Term Creep Life in Strength Enhanced High Cr Ferritic Steels,” Int. J. Pressure Vessels Piping, 87(6), pp. 276–281. [CrossRef]
Ghassemi-Armaki, H. , Chen, R. P. , Maruyama, K. , and Igarashi, M. , 2013, “ Contribution of Recovery Mechanisms of Microstructure During Long-Term Creep of Gr.91 Steels,” J. Nucl. Mater., 433(1–3), pp. 23–29. [CrossRef]
Maruyama, K. , Nakamura, J. , and Yoshimi, K. , 2014, “ Evaluation of Long-Term Creep Rupture Life of Strength Enhanced High Cr Ferritic Steel on the Basis of Its Temperature Dependence,” Advances in Materials Technology for Fossil Power Plants, D. Gandy , and J. Shingledecker , eds., ASM International, Materials Park, OH, pp. 732–743.
Masuyama, F. , 2015, “ Code Specification Issues and Life Prediction of Advanced Ferritic Steels for Power Generation,” First International Conference on Advanced High-Temperature Materials Technology for Sustainable and Reliable Power Engineering, Sapporo, Japan, June 29–July 3.
Strang, A. , and Vodarak, V. , 1998, “ Microstructural Degradation of Martensitic 12Cr Power Plant Steels During Prolonged High Temperature Creep Exposure,” Materials for Advanced Power Engineering 1998, J. Lecomte-Beckers , F. Shubert , and P. J. Ennis , eds., Forschungszentrum Julich GmbH, Julich, Germany, pp. 603–614.


Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 1

Stress dependence of rupture life together with regression curves (solid line) and lower boundary of 90% confidence bands (dotted line) obtained by conventional LM analysis of all the data. Data points of heat MGC are represented with the solid symbols.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 6

(a) Rupture life and (b) minimum creep rate of T91 steel in region L2. The solid regression lines were determined by LM analyses of the data in region L2 only.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 5

Creep rupture data (a) selected by σ0.2/2 criterion and (b) longer than 30,000 hrs. Solid lines are regression curves, and dotted lines are the lower boundary of 90% confidence bands. The solid symbols represent data points of heat MGC.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 4

(a) Stress and (b) temperature dependence of rupture life of heat MGC. The solid lines are regression curves determined by the multiregion analysis. Activation energies Q in the four regions are given in (b).

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 3

Correlation between data band (gray line) and its regression line (thin solid line) determined by SD analysis of the creep rupture data. The dotted lines are the upper and lower boundaries of a 90% confidence band.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 2

(a) SEE, (b) LM constant C, and rupture strength of (c) 5 × 105 hrs at 550 °C and (d) 105 hrs at 600 °C as a function of cut-off time taken for rupture data selection. σ0.2/2 and MRA stand for data selection based on σ0.2/2 criterion and multiregion analysis, respectively.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 7

Ni concentration dependence of rupture strength at (a) 5 × 105 hrs at 550 °C and (b) 105 hrs at 600 °C, and (c) deformation resistance at 10 −7 hr−1 at 600 °C

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 8

Rupture lives of three heats of plate products of Gr.91 steel together with the regression lines obtained in Fig. 6(a). Residual Ni concentrations of the three heats are given in the figure.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 9

Stress exponent n* at design lives (5 × 105 hrs at 550 °C and 105 hrs at 600 °C) as a function of cut-off time. MRA stands for the results obtained from analyses of the data in region L2 only.



Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.

Related Content

Customize your page view by dragging and repositioning the boxes below.

Related Journal Articles
Related eBook Content
Topic Collections

Sorry! You do not have access to this content. For assistance or to subscribe, please contact us:

  • TELEPHONE: 1-800-843-2763 (Toll-free in the USA)
  • EMAIL: asmedigitalcollection@asme.org
Sign In